Saturday, March 15, 2008

I'm sorry, but I hate manga so much.

I can't help it. I really hate manga. I live in Japan and see people every day on the trains reading Japanese comic books (manga) obsessively. They also stand in convenience stores reading the comics that are for sale there for hours.(Here's a long aside about that: for some reason, the store owners in Japan don't kick them out. Huge groups of guys here in Japan stand inside convenience stores in front of the manga and magazine racks just reading entire comic books from cover to cover. Hours. with. no. purchase. If I stood in 7-11 back home reading every magazine on the shelf for over an hour, I would almost definitely be asked to purchase the magazines or leave the store... but I guess it's like how back home, you can stay and read books for hours inside big chain bookstores like Chapters. Anyway, it's a way to kill time for free if you read Japanese.)I feel like if I liked reading manga, I could start with the kind with furigana (hiragana written all tiny above kanji, for people too young to read the kanji) and improve my Japanese vocabulary. Some people I know here used to read comics when they were younger and now they're really good at Japanese because they learned so many expressions from manga. I feel like if I started reading even translated popular manga I might learn something interesting about Japan. But it's so annoying! I don't like the art style of most typical Japanese manga, either. The Sailor Moon style drawings where every character looks exactly the same. I asked my friend to recommend a popular Japanese comic book to me and she gave me this manga called Nana that is extremely popular here. I tried to read it but the plot is like "The Parent Trap" for teenage girls. Two girls both named Nana, one is a quiet, boring girl and the other is this wild Nana in a punk band, they meet....alteregos, etc etc so boring. But it was so popular here that they made it into a movie. The thing that bothers me is that I don't hate comic books. I am not against graphic novels completely, so I could potentially like manga if I ever found a decent series. Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi is an amazing graphic novel that I have re-read many times in both French and English. It is smart, funny, sad, exciting. I can relate to the main character and it taught me some interesting things about life in Iran after the cultural revolution. That's the kind of comic book I like. Something wonderful that teaches me and entertains me at the same time.I heard that Persepolis was recently made into a film. I haven't seen it, but I'd be interested. Have any of you guys seen it? Anyway, one person who knows my tastes recommended that I read Doraemon comics. He bought me that English/Japanese version of the first Doraemon and even translated all the Kanji into furigana for me, which probably took ages. Anyway, it was adorable. This is a children's comic book but I liked it a lot. It was very charming, imaginative and sweet, about a very average boy who has a giant magical blue cat as his best friend. This children's comic is the only manga I have ever even vaguely enjoyed in Japan. In fact, that goes for movies, too. The only anime I like is made for children. I only like Totoro and Hayao Miyazaki animations.People here must read some kinds of smart, interesting comic books. Decent Japanese manga must exist. Can you recommend anything?

Also, I posted this last year, but now I have more people reading and commenting on this site so I will show it to you guys again. I made an online mix tape of all sorts of Japanese music I like. The theme was Japan, so most of the music is Japanese indie music. But the rules were that every song has to be either be by a completely Japanese band, sung in Japanese, about Japan, or the band must have at least one Japanese person in it. If you're interested in hearing some new / interesting Japanese independent music, here you go.

Also, I am moving to Kansai this month.

55 comments:

Lisa said...

I am nuts for Totoro! I don't care for manga either, although I did buy a comic about some cats while I was in Japan, with the intention of reading it to improve my Japanese. I also got a children's book to keep me busy until I learn some kanji, since the cat manga has kanji in it.

oreohmygosh said...

I'm not the biggest fan of manga either. All of my friends adore it; so, I tried to get into it so I could have more in common with them. Didn't work out too well.
However, I think Miyazaki films are beautiful, and they're among my most favorite movies.

Also, I'm a new reader to your blog, and I find it absolutely intriguing. I'm and English major and a Japanese minor at my University, and I've been wondering what I could do with my degree. Recently I've been thinking about teaching ESL in Japan. I find this blog to be very helpful =D

-Jackie

brokenmolar said...

The only manga I like is yotsuba&! (pronounced yotsubato). It's about a little girl living with her dad and learning all about the world and the things we see every day. It's really cute!

PS: your blog is my favorite.

Anonymous said...

I agree. My favorite anime is the work of Miyazaki as well. However, there is a good one called "Samurai Champloo". I would definitely recommend that to anyone. A young teen goes on a quest and along the way picks of a couple of body guards (for lack of a better word). They travel through historical Japan (mid-late 1800's I think) looking for the Samurai who smelled of sunflowers.

Dio said...

:3 I really like your blog!

If you like Doraemon, I would recommend Yotsuba&! It's a very sweet and funny story about a little girl growing up in Japan and the hijinks she gets into. As part of the story is her learning about the world/how things work, you'll be able to learn lots of different vocabularly.

amykwok said...

Hi there!

I actually got into reading Japanese manga in French when I was living in Paris because it helps with the everyday language. I learned new slang that I wouldn't learn from textbooks or novels. One of my absolute favorites was the Buddha series by Osamu Tezuka. It's really well written, light-hearted, funny at times, and overall an interesting history of Buddha.

I came upon your blog one day because I was teaching Conversational English in China was doing a search online for teaching english :) I find life in Japan fascinating...I want to learn Japanese now! (it also helps that my bf is japanese american :)) Keep up the blog!

Suhasini said...

I love Satrapi's comics as well. Persepolis was a great movie too!

Anonymous said...

I hate manga so much! I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it. But I must say: manga histories are soooo violent and they don't have anything interesting for intelectual and peacefull people ( like me or you ). If you read 1 of these books you will be interested for the history (those books are like drugs if you read one you one to read another) and no for your own exciting life! I was a manga and anime fan but things change with the time...

sj295 said...

my god, samurai champloo is absolutely the best and my fav manga too...my current fav is a femme fatale action called claymore...

Anonymous said...

Read Death Note...it has an amazing storyline. The animated show is almost as good too. Just be prepared to see some annoying females.

Naruto's drawing style is one of the most unique (you can't really tell by just looking at it) but once you look INTO the book you'll see REALLY kool women and men and stuff. But Naruto is like a japanese version of Harry Potter so the story is not as special.

If you like Spirited Away I reccomend Grave Of The Fireflies, which is the most powerful movie you shall ever see (I swear)

Look up Portus and Ringu and you'll get great ghost stories.

I know what you mean when you don't like drawing styles like Sailor Moon, but don't be thinking that that is the only style in asian graphic culture. All those books I gave you have great art in them.

Anonymous said...

Regarding the violent/darker aspects of Manga, it's a troubling thing I think, which the Japanophile apologists gloss over - last year I noticed a true crime manga on the shelves of the local Family Mart which actually dramatised the death of Lindsay Hawker, the EFL teacher from Britain. I couldn't believe what I was seeing..I don't want to go into details, but it depicted her assault and murder in a horribly sensationalist manner.

I felt quite ill..unfortunately I get the feeling that this kind of thing could only be published here.

Anonymous said...

You say, you hate Manga. Everybody has things whst he likes and what he doesn't like.
But...
You posted pictures of Anime and Real life movies (Nana Picture)
These are not manga, as you said you don't like manga don't mistake it for something different. If you also don't like the pictures then you'd have to say you don't like japanese animation.

Jeff said...

I love animes--Naruto, Bleach, Zero No Tsukaima, XxxHolic among others. But if you want to read a great manga, I would suggest Lone Wolf and Cub by Kazuo Koike and the artist Goseki Kojima...I think you would love the artwork:)

Akagi said...

Check out the Kaiji series (Tobaku Mokujiroku Kaiji, Tobaku Hakairoku Kaiji, and Tobaku Datenroku Kaiji) by Nobuyuki Fukumoto along with some of his other works.

Definitely not your typical moeblob generic manga. The mangaka has a very unorthodox art style that takes a little getting used to, but his writing is top-notch. He uses these various gambling scenarios to tell a somber tale about human paychology and nature along with one man's struggle to maintain his humanity while everyone around him has sold theirs for personal gain.

I'm not big on manga, but Fukumoto's stuff is excellent. My favorite work of his is Mahjong Legend Akagi, but you need to know some Reach mahjong to understand it.

kaylie said...

I very much loved Fruits Basket by Natsuki Takaya. But if you don't like Manga, what about Dramas? I super love Asian TV Doramas(not the ones for old people though), and you can learn from them as well.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, there are so many different types of manga that it's really hard to find ones you like. It really depends on your tastes, I suppose. I like CLAMP manga and really hate a lot of the manga people here have been pulling for (Fruits Basket, Nana, Bleach...), but I really love a lot of other manga. ^^;

Anonymous said...

manga sucks- my girlfriends obsessed with it and whenever i breathe near her when shes reading i get my head kicked in- it sucks

gi said...

I thought I should mention that my husband's absolute favorite comic is Jojo's Bizarre Adventure by Hirohiko Araki. It's got some fantastic artwork, and from what he tells me about the stories, he has some pretty imaginative stories and ideas. It's hard to categorize it, so I won't. Apparently my husband thinks that reading it in Japanese is essential to its "flavor" and "atmosphere", so that's probably why he doesn't really approve of the translated versions. One of his favorite scenes (out of a thousand scenes that are notable, he says) is when this character shows his skills and strength by smashing a rock. There is a frog on the rock, and although he hits the frog, the energy goes through the frog, leaving it unharmed, though mildly flattened, and the rock underneath it shatters into pieces. The part that makes this scene famous among Jojo fans (he says there are Mixi communities celebrating different scenes in Jojo comics) is the sound he invents to describe it: メメタァ. I'm looking forward to the day when I am fluent enough in Japanese to fully appreciate his comics.

Anonymous said...

For good compelling stories within manga you should read:

Berserk: Fantasy
Gantz: Sci-Fi
Monster: Thriller
Anything by Junji Ito

The trouble with most manga is like music, there's always generic, mediocre material abundant in the mainstream but if you're willing to search beyond that, you're bound to find hidden treasures.

Anonymous said...

Hmm...

try this:
1. find a manga you might find interesting at the bookstore.
2. open it, read it, see if you like it.

If you don't like it:
Put it down and walk away or find another one to read.
If you do like it:
Read more, maybe buy it if your that interested.
______________________

Manga is a Japanese equivalent to Comic books so it's main goal is obviously not intellectual and thought provoking storyline.
Like Anonymous said:

"The trouble with most manga is like music, there's always generic, mediocre material abundant in the mainstream but if you're willing to search beyond that, you're bound to find hidden treasures."

^_^

Julie said...

Thanks for not only posting the dumbest comment I have ever received, but for doing so anonymously. 0% value.

Anonymous said...

A manga I'd recommend is "With the Light: Raising an Autistic Child". From what I've read (which is about half of the 1st book) it's a wonderful story, if not a bit fluffy at times. It's a josei, so it's intended for for late teenaged/adult female readers. =3

thecatalyst13 said...

If you want something thought provoking go with the manga Death Note. It revolves around a young man who now has the ability to write down a name in a notebook and kill them. He wants to rid the world of criminals. Makes you think about morality and has many twists/turns.

If you enjoy fantastic story-telling and characters watch the anime Cowboy Bebop. If after getting to the episode Ballad of Fallen Angels you don't love it. I will send you money. Everyone I've shown that anime has loved it. Plus it has the best soundtrack you will ever hear from a movie or tv show. I have the box set of the music and listen to it on its own. I watch the entire series at least once every year and introduce it to a new person. Also, there is a movie adaptation currently in the works-- hopefully they won't ruin it. Cowboy Bebop has so much depth a masters thesis could be written on it. In fact, I'm gonna try and work it in to mine somehow. Just found your blog and love it. Thanks for sharing with us!

Elise said...

I've been reading a manga called, The Liar Game, and it is grown up and actually causes you to think.

It is about a way too honest naive girl who gets caught up in something called the liar game, and a con artist she asks to help her. There is no love story or anything (so far), just trying to find ways to survive and escape this game.

This is way after the fact, so I'm not sure if you will see this, but it is currently the favorite thing I am reading. Akuma to love song (devil's love song) is also one I enjoy, but it is set in high school.

Oh and I love your blog, I'm very happy to have found it!

fuyupon said...

I think you might like Chii's Sweet Home by Konami Kanata, it's a story about the life of a young cat, it's really cute, the art style is pretty cute. Sketchbook by Kobako Totan and Sket Dance by Shinohara Kenta are pretty light hearted & funny imo.

Nodame Cantabile by Ninomiya Tomoko, Piano no Mori by Isshiki Makoto, Hourou Musuko by Shimura Takako are more slightly more serious stories, but still have a 'cute' art style.

I can't think of any other manga to recommend though. I usually read shounen manga, I'm not a huge fan of shoujou manga. . . The huge moe eyes weird me out sometimes.

Bri said...

I admit, I am one of the manga geeks. There are many Manga and Anime I refuse to watch because they are downright juvenile. D:

Hmmm...Yotsuba&! is really good. It has good humor, and it's clean. Very adorable as well.

I recommend that one above all else on the top of my head.

Anime-wise...xxxHolic is interesting. Other than the main character flipping out every 10 minutes, there is a lot you can learn from it. The stories are captivating and teach valuable life lessons. xD

mike said...

I agree with your comment about Nana. THE most boring anime (manga) I've ever seen! I don't really much care for manga either, but I do like to watch anime. And Nana, flat out sucked.

Sapphi said...

I recommend anything by Leiji Matsumoto, but especially Galaxy Express 999. His style is very unique and wonderfully retro and his stories are one of a kind. :3

tony said...

hello there~ just come across to your blog because of Namie PV (i'm her fan since forever~) by the way i red about the manga comment of yours, i think japan's anime & manga has developed many trends nowadays, i'm sure there is one out there suit you, me wise i born in hong kong and has been working in uk for more than 10 years, japanese tv shows and anime keeps me growing because i found most of UK tv are simply plain boring and one too many reality show...anyway, if you like morality / something make you wonder i recommand you watch "mushishi", the pen style is more conventional (no super big eyed character etc...haha)each ep. is a diff. story of a man's journey, give it a go~
i found your page interesting becoz i'm planning to go back to asia in not too far future and japan is one place i want to work in~

anything just drop me a email, nice to meet you :)

tung4fds@hotmail.com

Theresia said...

hi there, i'm a nobody. came across your blog and read this post.

if you like Satrapi, you might want to check out Yoshihiro Tatsumi:

http://www.drawnandquarterly.com/artStudio.php?artist=a41e32e169aff2
http://manga.about.com/od/mangaartistinterviews/a/YTatsumi.htm


cheers :)
theresia

franzeska said...

I used to love all that kiddie shit when I was... guess what, a kiddie. It's so sad that now that I can more or less read most manga, I've lost interest in most of what I used to like. (And now it's even being translated into English! 10 years too late! Boo!)

That said, there are only a billion comics out there for other tastes. (None in English, of course, but if you can read Japanese, you've got your pick.) If you don't like the fugly Sailor Moon art, I suggest Hatoyama Ikuko, Okano Reiko, and Yamada Akihiro.

http://www5d.biglobe.ne.jp/~calico/04-@spangle/@spangle-top.html
http://www.najanaja.co.jp/index.html
http://kirakuya-honpo.hustle.ne.jp/yamada-akihiro/

Hatoyama is known for publishing in Garo (a defunct avant garde manga mag well known for both its weirdness and its quality). Okano does adaptations of things like those Onmyouji novels (Yumemakura Baku) and The Forgotten Beasts of Eld. She's very big on mythology. Yamada is also an illustrator, and it shows in his manga art. I'm partial to the 1-volume Hyakka Teien no Higeki (百花庭園の悲劇). It's a hard boiled sf/f detective story set in "Neo-Hong Kong". (So 1980s near future dystopian sci fi!)

Generally, if you want manga that is *actually* for intelligent adults (as opposed to Nana and other things people like to *tell* you are for intelligent adults), you have to look for the weirder magazines and imprints. I go to bookoff and just look for the "other" section where they stash all the publishers who aren't big enough to have their own sections.

If you want something with more serious social content, try Barefoot Gen or Town of Evening Calm, Country of Cherry Blossoms. People have compared the former to Maus for years. I haven't read the latter yet, but it looks pretty good.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barefoot_Gen
http://manga.about.com/od/lastgasp/gr/TownofEvening1.htm

If you want something easy to read but not so painful an adult can't get through it, try Yotsubato! It's a slice of life manga about a cute 4 year old and her various neighbors. (I see everyone has mentioned this already.)

If you want something classic, try any of the Year 24 Group or Post-Year 24 Group. Some of their work is decidedly for kids and is sf/f or doomed gay romance stuff. However, they're the ones the next several generations of comics artists were ripping off, so they often seem surprisingly readable/un-derivative/fresh/whatever even if you're not a big fan of the stuff that came later. Hagio Moto is currently sporadically publishing a series of vaguely connected oneshots called "Anywhere But Here". The first collected volume should be available. It's called Yama e Iku. It's got a bunch of stories about hating family reunions, dealing with family members with brain injuries, etc. along with a bunch of magical realism.

If you want something more Western, try those Jeeves and Wooster or Agatha Christie manga adaptations.

franzeska said...

Whatever you do, don't listen to those suggestions for things like Death Note and Naruto. Not that I dislike those--they're great in their way--but they're the same standard stuff you've already said you don't like. Just keep in mind that manga are usually serialized first in magazines, and those magazines can have extremely different target audiences. Anything from Shounen Jump, Shounen Sunday, etc. (where everything like Naruto can be found) is going to be mainstream in the extreme. Anything from Flowers has a vague chance of being for adult women. Any 4koma (i.e. comic strips) from women's magazines that aren't 100% manga are going to be about realistic adult women's problems. Just go to a Bookoff or some used store and flip through things until you find an art style you like. The range of manga published in Japanese is like the range of fiction published in English (novels, series, short stories, avant garde weirdness, sci fi, biographies, ...). The range of manga published in English or scanlated for English-speaking audiences is like the range of comic books published in English: you might find the occasional one that's a bit like Persepolis, but 99.9999999% of them will be aimed squarely at some specific geek market that may not share your tastes.

Manga is NOT the equivalent to comic books, at least not if that person meant the American sort. Manga is the equivalent of bande dessinée. Some of it is crap for kids. Some of it has thought-provoking writing and graphic-design-y art for adults.

Anonymous said...

I find it mildly offensive that just because you didn't enjoy something, you deem it not "smart and interesting". Personally, I loved Nana.

Other than that, I would recommend Paradise Kiss, which is written by the same person as Nana, but shorter, a little more abstract, and tells a little bitter story of life.

Anonymous said...

I think manga is quite ugly. It's like thousands of artists are redrawing Mickey Mouse over and over again. In the seventies the Netherlands were invaded with manga style cartoons. All characters seemed to be twins of each other with their big eyes that only know a few expressions like excitement, fear and brave. Mouths are small when closed end extremely big when opened. Of course filled with teeth. The repeating moving backgrounds with flashes and colors against stills... man.
But I appreciate it also. It's definitely a culture and as long people like it or even become inspired to make art themselves it's OK.

Ana said...

hey, i´m also living in japan, and i´m an illustrator so in love with manga...wrong only certain manga...it is true some manga ( mostly soujo) falls into cliche, but i think i can recomend you something interesting...if you want a popular one..GINTAMA ( is not that much about the drawing, but the history) It´s a parody between japanese history and nowadays society..the more you read it the funnier it gets.
If you want somenthing more "serious" try MONONOKE from ninagawa yaeko..the drawing style is beutiful and is like folk tales of old japan...
hey if you like any of them i can recomend you some more...RUN AWAY FROM THE EVERYDAY SHOUJO!!!!

Vegancat said...

http://manga.animea.net/vagabond-chapter-1-page-1.html

Maybe you can find it written in japanese?

The story is brilliant and historical...bit much of violence but hey...that is just how it was i guess?

And the way it is drawn...classic. Not really a typical manga, or?

Anonymous said...

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Art that you find revolting in some manga might actually be appealing to others.
I have to admit I really like Nana and I think that the series deserves all the attention it gets. I see no justification in bashing a manga series after only reading a mere tenth of the whole thing.
However, I do agree with your take on Hayao Miyazaki films. They are simply inspiring and ever-so magical.

Anonymous said...

I would suggest anything written by takeshi obata
(death note,bakuman,blue dragon ral Grad,etc.)
I for one love manga and I'm currently working on my own series now

Anonymous said...

I like Hetalia but I'm a history nerd. Most of Hetalia is short though. The anime episodes are 5 minutes and the webcomic reads like the comics from the Sunday Newspaper.

I also like Nihonjin ga Shiranai Nihongo. There's a drama for that now too. I feel like I'm learning something when I'm reading it.

Matt Narciso | Teaching ESL Students said...

I couldn't believe what I was hearing, because my own experience is utterly opposite: Anime and Manga are quite possibly the least creative, most rule-infested genre of art. I can speak with some authority on this subject because I've lived in Japan (the home of anime and manga) for seven years.

In relation to this, you may want to visit our online English academy is bases in Cebu City, Philippines. It is an institution with competent, effective, and efficient ESL teachers well-equipped to provide easy and fun way of learning English at a minimum amount of time per session.

Anonymous said...

Ironically, you posted picutres of my two favorite animes, Bleach and Ouran High School Host club. Hard to believe someone could hate it, theres tons of mangas, many of them aren't lacking intellgence and gushing out violence like you say. Maybe give it a try? Something so popular can't be all hype right?

Anonymous said...

Try:
バカ姉弟
聖おにいさん
あずまんが大王
よつばと
猫ラーメン

These are totally different from typical shoujo or young adults' manga. The art works and story lines are simple, but they are all filled with memorable characters. Some are translated in English (Azumanga Daioh and Yotsuba &).

Anonymous said...

I love manga "Kyo no Nekomura san"
It is very popular in Japan.
but, never popular in Foreign country.

In some bookstore,
it is not on manga shelf.
but on Literature shelf!

AstroNerdBoy said...

I'd love to ask you a few questions for an article I'm working on at the moment based on your article here.

Anonymous said...

あなたは、私がそれを示してきましたデスノートみんなを読み取る必要がありますそれを愛している

Anonymous said...

Greetings from Nova Scotia... I really enjoy your blog, moving to Japan is something I might like to do in the future.
Maybe you'd like Spice and Wolf. It is so pretty and the story line is mature.

Veronica said...

Haha this is awesome.

I have a love-hate relationship with manga since my job is teaching comics and storytelling at a museum school.

Old school stuff like Osamu Tezuka's work and Toriyama's "Dr. Slump" are super awesome, but nothing recent appeals to me at all.

But I think it's natural that the market is so oversaturated with crap that the really good gems are hard to find.

Maybe more of an indie manga genre is forming! That would be cool.

Anonymous said...

i recommend chibi maruko chan

Anonymous said...

Haha, funny. I don't read much manga either, but the one manga I DO love is NANA. :P

I have to say I'm confused about your comparison of it to "The Parent Trap," though. I mean, the two women just have the same name (which, I'm pretty sure isn't in The Parent Trap). They aren't twins and they never switch places in order to trick their parents into getting back together... in other words, they have nothing in common... Um.. Yeah. *shrug*

makhan said...

The best shounen manga (btw absolutely the best manga ever) - One Piece
The best shoujou manga - Skip Beat!
Miyazaki's manga - Nausicaa


Try all of the above, maybe you'll like one of them :) Manga comes in many kinds, I'm sure there is something you'd like ;)

Tiffany said...

I don't read much manga, so cannot really recommend much but animewise here are a couple you may/may not enjoy -

Serial Experiements Lain as a interesting and thought provoking anime - it's fairly dark but mostly non violent, blurring the borders of reality, memory and the digital world. Sometimes pacing can be a little confusing, so it's worth a couple of watches. It's relatively short - just 13 episodes.

Paranoia agent is also exceedingly interesting, it looks at mass media, the relationship that the public have with it and it;s bearing on their everyday lives ... it's essentially a psychological thriller and has vaguely upernatural elements. This may be darker than you'd normally be into - I dunno.

Millenium Actress - a beautiful film about two men filming a documentary about a retired actress - as they interview her and she tells them about her life, the facts and her roles become intermingled and they are swept up in the storytelling.

You might also really enjoy Tokyo Godfathers, I bought it recently very cheaply. It's about 3 homeless people who discover an abandoned baby at christmas and their actions to care for it. As the story unfolds you learn more about their personal circumstances and how they came to live on the streets ... it's laugh out loud funny at points and gut wrenching in more than a few others.

in as non pretentious undickish aside as possible (doomed to fail) - I'd hesitate to class ghibli movies as being solely for children ... there is a lot of stuff in ghibli movies that children wouldn't necessarily grasp ... eg Princess Mononoke - the lack of a black and white presence of good/evil ...

My Neigbour Totoro is a stunning film, but very much about nothing - my young cousins got bored whilst watching it because not much happens, yet I love it, because it reminded me of when I was small ...

Howl's moving castle - although bright and colourful and very much enjoyed by my younger brother, the messages about romance, self love, self worth, confidence etc went straight over his head ...

I would also never show Grave of the Fireflies to a child ... that is one of the most heartbreaking films ever made - no less so because it is animated.

It's not true of all ghibli movies -Kiki's delivery Service and The Cat Returns are fairly light hearted, both have themes around the importance of self worth/believing in yourself but they're mostly just fantastic adventure stories ...

ANYWAY - I hope you discover something you enjoy!

Anonymous said...

Death Note-outstanding animation/illustration, a great plot, and the characters are very interesting. It really makes you rethink your views. I recommend both the anime and manga because both are exquisite.

macey said...

Ok i know what you mean. Most of the manga i've ever read are all repeats and same plot pish posh but out there there are some really great ones! Some are just really long and some of the best don't have the greatest pictures because they focus a lot on the plot. "Boys Over Flowers" is one like that. It was made in like the 90s and it's my favorite one yet! Oh you must read it maybe it will change your mind! But don't give up on manga. Look for the ones with really japanese sounding names (Boys over flowers was called Hana Yori Dango when i first read it! cute huh?) I can recommend so many to you my head and most likely yours would explode but seeing as most are just along same plot lines there really is no point. But don't just generically group almost all manga together. Maybe you've just read some bad ones. Also i LOVED NANA don't even try to diss it (even if you are allowed to have your own opinion). The characters may be ditzy and frustrating and downright cheesy but it is actually a heart tugging manga. Also i soooooooo agree with the Hayao Miyazaki! Man can that guy make movies!! Can't wait for more from him!

macey said...

I think the reason i like manga and anime (i'm way more into manga now a days) is because it's like your watching somebody's life unfold before your eyes. Some are corny and repetitive but sometimes having those same stories told to you by different artists and characters is what makes reading them over and over again a treat. But manga also can teach one something about their self. I was once reading this manga in 7th grade just to pass the time because i was bored of homework and nobody was home. Well when i clicked on this seemingly random piece i could not stop reading it until 4 hours later and i realized it ended. I cried my eyes out because of the way too sweet plot and the great art and the message that came along with it. "Follow your heart and let every moment be a step forward towards your future" i admit a very generic lesson but it really stuck with me. The girl in that manga, she wanted to be a children's editor but she was horrible at interviews. Well she meets this guy at an interview and same on the train (Yes this is a shojo manga, THERE WILL BE ROMANCE AND CORNY SCENES, but those are the scenes i live for. They're just so perfect.) and he teaches her something. To have strength and confidence. Well let's just say after that good read my life long dream is to be a book editor for random house fiction, not necessarily children's books though. So i suppose it depends on the person. I get an enjoyment out of reading these transporting books and some people hate how most are tedious and unsatisfying. Hey that's your opinion. But don't give up on all of them. You just have to find the one that speaks to you the most. That's when you know you've got a keeper.

Anonymous said...

It's the same as picking a movie to watch, you need to know what you are looking for. Find a site where you can search for recommendations, similar books and authors like myanimelist.

Anime: Grave of the Fireflies
Manga: Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan
Both very moving and my top picks.

More anime: Paprika, She and Her Cat, Perfect Blue, Genius Party, Detroit Metal City, Texhnolyze, Mind Game, Aoi Bungaku
More manga: Nijigahara Holograph, Vagabond, Berserk, Monster

I saw Persepolis the movie and I really enjoyed it, I never read the comic tho so I don't know how it compares.